Daily Dish of Dominey Design
{  June 7, 2004  }

All Aboard the Airport Express

Most of the time I'm very cautious before plunking down hard earned cash on technology. I read reviews, check out user forums, and ask around. But when Apple unveiled Airport Express with AirTunes earlier today, I didn't think twice. Hell, I didn't think at all. I quickly perused the descriptive text, and headed straight for the register.

I have waited years for a product like this -- an elegant, easy, simple way to wirelessly stream music from my Mac to my stereo without running a hundred feet of cable (which I've done, and it looks like crap), or burning piles of wasteful MP3 CDs just so I can hear my collection in the living room. I looked at the latest Tivos, intrigued by their audio / video capabilities, in addition to the other third-party wireless mp3 streamers, but was often turned off by price and size. Plus, I always had a feeling Apple would enter the living-room space at some point, and when they did, they'd leapfrog the competition.

Apple did enter that space today, but instead of leapfrogging other products on the market, they drove around the competition, and filled a niche most people hadn't considered -- a portable wireless router that fits in the palm of your hand, can be plugged in just about anywhere, can share a USB printer, and (if you already have a wireless network) extend the range of your signal. And of course there is the stereo jack, which you can run into any device with speakers anywhere within range of your computer, and stream all the audio you want.

The genius of Airport Express, to me, is that instead of fighting it out with set-top box manufacturers and established stereo companies and offering an all-in-one media center box, Apple designed a simple, relatively inexpensive gateway that gives consumers what they really want -- a bridge between their computer, and their existing stereo equipment, without the need to buy all new equipment. Airport Express adds on to what people already have, without fuss, cables, or headaches. And unlike bulky stereo rack units, you can move AirportExpress anywhere, plug it into practically anything with speakers, and hear music wherever you want.

And the best part? You don't have to own a Mac either.

The one drawback is that Airport Express doesn't provide a remote, or an interface, to control iTunes from wherever you are. Apple's publicity material mentions you can use your 'iBook as a kind of superpowered remote control,' and there already exists freeware / shareware software to control a remotely running copy of iTunes on your LAN, but that again requires a computer to use.

Personally, I'd bet one of the smart accessory manufacturers (like Griffin Technology or Dr. Bott) will fill this void.

And speaking of predictions, don't forget about the iPod. Airport Express practically guarantees a wifi-capable iPod which can access the network and stream music directly from the palm of your hand. Imagine walking into your house, switching the audio output on your iPod to wireless, removing the headphones from your ears, and hearing the same music, with little interruption, playing through your home stereo. Now that is even better. All in good time.

Comments

I was brainstorming right after I read the announcement, and I thought that my Palm would make a great remote. S.E. Clicker combined with my Tungsten T will allow me to remote control from anywhere on my main floor (bluetooth range kinda sucks). I was thinking that you could probably hack something with AppleScript to work with the Tungsten C (or any Pocket PC device with WiFi). You would just need some type of shell to connect to your Mac.

Posted by: Jon Lane at June 7, 2004 8:14 PM

This really is a great product. I had built a home theater pc for much of these same reasons, and will continue to use it, but will definitely look into this little device. THe cost is so low for what it does, heck, I'd almost get it just to extend the range of my AP. I could walk around with my Powerbook and control the music, or I could use my SE Z600 bt enabled phone and use SE Clicker as previously mentioned to control the tunes. The possiblities are really great with this product... Well done Apple!

Posted by: Seth Messer at June 7, 2004 8:51 PM

As Jon says, you can use a bluetooth device as a remote. For me, that's a Nokia 3620 with the Sailing Clicker (http://homepage.mac.com/jonassalling/Shareware/Clicker/)

Posted by: Greg Pfeil at June 7, 2004 9:11 PM

I very nearly almost plunked down my hard earned $120 this very morning as well. Until I read about how the AirportExpress actually works.

Rather than allowing a single (or, as I desired, multiple) AirpotExpres(ses) to exist as nodes on your WiFi network, they act more like targets. From iTunes, you pick a target you want to play to, and start streaming -- the music is encoded as Apple Lossless on the fly and played. Actually, pretty elegant way of dealing with myriad file formats.

Except that it's unclear as to whether or not this allows for playing multiple streams throughout the house. Can I listen to Miles in the kitchen while the gf listens to Shirley Horn in the living room? Don't know, and from what I've read, probably not. Also, the lack of a remote control of some sort really dampens my enthusiasm. Yes, this screams for a small wifi enabled handheld device of some sort, but until then, my $120 is staying put.

As for a WiFi enabled iPod, I can't wait, though I'm more excited about building ad-hoc music networks on the bus to work than I am about co-opting a solution that already works in my house. But I also live in a city that has a worthwhile public transportation system ;^) (sorry ATL...)

Posted by: Jim Ray at June 7, 2004 9:25 PM

that's an interesting article. i'm really interested in knowing what the load on the machine is to decompress, compress, then encrypt audio. as it stands itunes can chew up a decent amount of memory during it's use. while running something like this on a g5 is probably hardly noticable, i'll bet a pc will show it's "inabilities" fairly quickly. though, most likely itunes 4.6 will look at the file, and if it's compressed using the lossless compression, itunes will simply encrypt the stream and then send it forward to the device. it's also interesting to not that not even a month ago the com sdk was released. i haven't had a chance to play with it, but i'll be interested in seeing what else is created.

Posted by: mosquito at June 7, 2004 9:44 PM

I think you have found what is commonly referred to as a "synergistic satisfier" see http://www.environmental-center.com/magazine/inderscience/ijsd/art2.pdf
Go apple!

Posted by: Jbennett at June 8, 2004 12:47 AM

While I am still trying to figure out how can the AirPort Express feed music signal to my rather no-tech stereo, I figure out that for those of us with a Bluetooth phone and Salling Clicker, that's a feasible way to obtain remote-like capabilities with iTunes, although the stability of a Bluetooth connection leaves something to be desired with my now-ancient t68i.

Posted by: beto at June 8, 2004 3:35 AM

Posted by: Nathan at June 8, 2004 11:35 AM

Man, this is like watching an army mobilize for an attack. Each piece is coming together, and is cool in its own right, but when the entire force is put together, it will be difficult to contend with.

And I think it's not just audio around your home, but video as well. Just a matter of time.

Posted by: Jon Bell at June 8, 2004 11:58 AM

Add wi-fi to the iPod and you essentially get the equivalent of the new sonos system: http://www.sonos.com/products/

Their controller is clearly based on the iPod, but they want $1200 for a two room system. Apple's system would come in at around half for two zones. It's not amplified like sonos, but considering most people already have stereos in the rooms where they want music, amplification is somewhat redundant.

What I'd like to see is the ability for the music to follow you from room to room, which should be fairly simple to do once the ipod has wi-fi.

Posted by: endo at June 8, 2004 12:48 PM

iTunes lets you do the selecting and browsing, if that is what you are looking for: This is a personal radio station. NO REMOTE REQUIRED.

Posted by: PSandiford at June 8, 2004 1:22 PM

A Wi-Fi equipped iPod is about the only thing that would motivate me to buy an Airport Express, because then I could effectively use the iPod as a remote. As it is now, I have an iPod and I have a dock, and the dock is connected to my stereo. So I can already walk into the house, plunk my iPod into the dock, and keep listening to music on my home stereo. I don't need Airport Express for that.

Posted by: brad at June 8, 2004 1:24 PM

Hmmm a wifi ipod with a video screen that shows the available wifi connections. 2 folks in the house requesting different music shouldnt be a problem. :) Random thoughts.

Posted by: Kessa at June 8, 2004 3:10 PM

In addition to a WiPod, the idea of being able to do wireless video (from my computer to TV) is pretty attractive, especially since I do not own a DVD player apart from the one in my Powerbook. Not only would it be nice for watching films, but it would make viewing slideshows in iPhoto a lot more fun. I bet it won't be long before that'll happen.

Posted by: brad at June 8, 2004 4:19 PM

It is strange that they don't use the word "wireless router" anywhere in their description. From what I can tell it *is* a wireless router.

As I am looking to purchase a wireless router, I am seriously considering this product. I had to read deep down into the tech specs to discern whether it provided similar capabilities to my Linksys router (firewall etc.), which it sounds like it does. I also wonder what its signal strength is like.


Posted by: Daniel Wabyick at June 8, 2004 5:54 PM

Yep, it's a wireless router. I haven't seen anything about the range, but it is limited to 10 users at a time, not a problem in a home but not great if you're hoping to use it to make instant wireless available in a conference room full of geeks.

If you have any computers on your network that don't have a WiFi card (i.e. if any of your computers is connected directly to your Linksys router via Ethernet), this product won't be adequate...it's for wireless-only networks as it doesn't have a LAN port, only WAN (which is used to connect your cable or DSL modem, for example).

Posted by: brad at June 8, 2004 5:58 PM

God Bless You Todd! I was hoping peope like you would buy these suckers. Then you can let us all know if it's worth buying. Todd is my technology fullback. I'll miss that tackle, "Todd take that tackle," spin move, END ZONE!!! JIM SCORES!!!

"I like to thank all the people that helped me score the winning (tech) touchdown: Mama, Jesus, Elvis and Todd Dominey."

Posted by: Jim at June 8, 2004 6:52 PM

Well, the showstopper for me right now is that it won't play streams, and here in Atlanta, where the NPR is way below average, we play streams from NPR stations in Chapel Hill, Seattle, Santa Monica and elsewhere all the time to get our kul-chur. And news.
Does anyone know why AirTunes has this limitation?

Posted by: jcburns at June 8, 2004 10:50 PM

Cool, gotta check this out more!

Posted by: swimp at June 9, 2004 9:59 AM

"Imagine walking into your house, switching the audio output on your iPod to wireless, removing the headphones from your ears, and hearing the same music, with little interruption, playing through your home stereo. "

Now imagine the future iPod ...with 802.11 and Bluetooth.

(edit)
Imagine walking into your house, your iPod's Bluetooth automatically detects your stereo and switches the audio output on your iPod to wireless, keep your Bluetooth headphones on your ears (since they don't have a plug), and hearing the same music, with little interruption, playing through your home stereo.

I can't wait for the future! :)

Posted by: eduardo at June 12, 2004 9:28 AM

there already exists freeware / shareware software to control a remotely running copy of iTunes on your LAN

I've looked around, but haven't found this -- any recommendations?

Posted by: Rosecrans Baldwin at June 14, 2004 6:43 AM

Wow lots of geeks here ;) I ordred one though!!! I can't wait to scare the piss out of my roomates when the walk into the house and music strats pumping through the speakers!! I havn't told them I got it yet!!! hehe!!!
now ti pimp my web site!!! Pimping It Big

Posted by: Caleb at June 15, 2004 11:46 AM

Nokia 6600 with Salling Clicker, and loving it. Despite how much Bluetooth's limited range sucks.

Posted by: Kiran Jonnalagadda at June 19, 2004 8:13 AM

Your web site is stunning *envy drool*

I am ashamed of my sin. I just created a non-standards web site because is seemed easier.

I won't even post a link to it I am so ashamed.

tom

Posted by: tom at June 28, 2004 2:42 PM

archives

You are reading "All Aboard the Airport Express" in the individual archives.

Check out other recent posts in the Apple category

Return to the front page.