Blogger Backlash?
So today the weblog world and technology presses are basically freaking out because Google has purchased Pyra, the company behind Blogger. While most people seem to be in favor of the move, and dreaming up all kinds of cross-media integration ideas, I can't help but wonder what will happen to the community surrounding the tool. Like indie rock, or any "independent," non-corporate scene, once an artist, a band, or underground community sticks their head above street level and into the gleaming skyscrapers of corporate America, something dies along the way. Of course we are talking about Google, which arguably isn't as corporate as, say, Yahoo!, but at the same time I can't help but wonder how positive a development this really is. With extra financing and support, Blogger will almost certainly grow into an even more powerful tool for independent content creators, but at what cost to their community? Time will tell.
Comments
I am a paying Blogger Pro subscriber and I am very happy to see this. I was just about ready to drop them. I was having so many problems, and there wasn’t any real support to get problems fixed. There wasn’t anyone who could really answer your questions. Support was terrible. I was never able to get “archives” to work correctly, and publishing sometimes worked, and when it did for some reason it took 10 minutes before it would show up on your site.
Also, there hasn’t been any new functionality added in a long time especially compared to MT. I had easily outgrown the service. The only reason I stayed with them was because I had spent a lot of time developing a custom template that integrated nicely into my site.
The only thing that will “die along the way” is the lack of updates, bad service, and the lack of help when you need it.
Posted by: Woody at February 16, 2003 1:31 PM
I agree, Woody. The paying users are the only one to benefit from this, with the non-paying users (both Blogger and BlogSpot) seeing their services drastically cut. Blogger will most likely end up creating some sort of "forced upgrade"- making free services so shoddy, that no one would dare use it. And who can blame them? Ev and gang deserve to make money from their work.
Posted by: Ryan at February 16, 2003 5:51 PM
I admit that Blogger is a great tool. AFAIK Blogger never made much money... yet helped create the "sensation" that is blogging. I am glad to see the Pyra folks make some money from their efforts... and if someone had to buy them out, better Google than you know who! ;)
But when MoveableType sells to the highest bidder... I'll lift a beer in sorrow.
Posted by: Apostle at February 16, 2003 10:46 PM
Ryan, I don't think Google will do anything to Bloggers current state of the free resource. Take a look at Google Groups, New, Froogle, etc. All of these services are free of charge (unless something has happened in the last hour that I am unaware of.
If anything, this will really bring blogging to the masses in ways that Moveable Type and Radio can not.
My question is this, what happens when everyone is blogging? Who will blog the bloggers?
Posted by: Greg at February 16, 2003 11:20 PM
I would give Google the benfit of the doubt, considering their code of conduct: Don't Be Evil.
Posted by: Boz at February 17, 2003 9:09 AM
This is great news. I don't know how people have put up with blogger for this long. I've been fighting with it for the past month, (trying to help a friend with her blog) and it's been more than frustrating. There's basically no support. None. If you have a problem, you're screwed. I've come to hate it.
Posted by: Mel at February 17, 2003 11:10 AM
While I'd agree that corporate America has the ability to ruin an independent scene, I think the difference here is that with a few exceptions, blogging is not about making money. I don't use a content management tool, so all I need is Notepad and I'm off and running. With blogging, content is personal; the tools of production can be exploited (and ruined) but the content is in the hands of the little people.
Posted by: Beerzie Boy at February 17, 2003 4:31 PM
I don't understand why people complain about Blogger's lack of support- it's free. And Blogger isn't necessary- there's always xanga and livejournal, etc. Google won't be evil, and has so many people watching it's search engine mechanics that blogger people will not end up with some preferential rankings simply because they use Blogger rather than another content management tool. The move could only make Blogger more effective (in terms of reliability and speed)- under the assumption that Google servers/tech is used.
my two cents.
Posted by: duke at February 17, 2003 9:44 PM
Free??? HA! We've spent over $200 bucks with blogger this year. Since there's no support, there was no way to transfer the domain/blog/account name. We were forced to open a second pro.blogger account just to change the URL. We chose blogger because it was the only web app my friend was able to access from Uzbekistan.
Posted by: Mel at February 18, 2003 9:03 AM
